Quick answer
What is extreme emotional disturbance in New York?
Extreme emotional disturbance (EED) is an affirmative defense to intentional murder under Penal Law § 125.25(1)(a). If the defendant proves he acted under an extreme emotional disturbance with a reasonable explanation or excuse, the jury convicts of manslaughter in the first degree instead of murder.
What is the extreme emotional disturbance defense?
Under Penal Law § 125.25(1)(a), it is an affirmative defense to intentional murder that the defendant acted under the influence of extreme emotional disturbance for which there was a reasonable explanation or excuse, judged from the viewpoint of a person in the defendant's situation under the circumstances as the defendant believed them to be. The same defense applies to first-degree murder under Penal Law § 125.27(2)(a).
EED does not lead to an acquittal. It is a mitigating defense: a successful EED defense converts intentional murder into manslaughter in the first degree under Penal Law § 125.20(2), a class B violent felony with a determinate sentence of 5 to 25 years, instead of an indeterminate sentence of up to life.
What must the defense prove? The two-part Casassa test
In People v. Casassa, 49 N.Y.2d 668 (1980), the Court of Appeals explained that EED has two parts:
- Subjective: the defendant actually acted under the influence of an extreme emotional disturbance at the time of the killing; and
- Objective: there was a reasonable explanation or excuse for that disturbance, judged from the viewpoint of a person in the defendant's situation under the circumstances as the defendant believed them to be.
In People v. Roche, 98 N.Y.2d 70 (2002), the Court explained that the defense requires proof of a mental infirmity, not rising to the level of insanity, that caused a loss of self-control at the time of the homicide. Psychiatric testimony is not always required, but there must be real evidence of both elements. In Roche, the Court held the charge was properly refused because the defendant's calculated behavior — fabricating a story and concealing evidence after the killing — was inconsistent with a loss of self-control.
Who has the burden of proof?
Because EED is an affirmative defense, the defendant must prove it by a preponderance of the evidence (Penal Law § 25.00(2)). The prosecution still must prove every element of murder beyond a reasonable doubt. In Patterson v. New York, 432 U.S. 197 (1977), the U.S. Supreme Court upheld New York's placement of this burden on the defendant, affirming People v. Patterson, 39 N.Y.2d 288 (1976).
How is an EED defense built?
- Psychiatric notice. If the defense will offer psychiatric evidence in support of EED, it must serve notice under CPL 250.10, and the prosecution may then have the defendant examined by its own expert.
- The defendant's history and the events leading up to the killing — relationships, stressors and the defendant's mental condition — presented through witnesses, records and expert testimony.
- The defendant's conduct and words before and after the event, which juries weigh closely.
- The jury charge. The court must instruct on EED when the evidence, viewed in the light most favorable to the defendant, would allow a jury to find both elements by a preponderance.
The statute bars the defense when the disturbance resulted solely from the discovery, knowledge or disclosure of the victim's actual or perceived sexual orientation, sex, gender, gender identity or gender expression.
How is EED different from insanity and from New Jersey's passion/provocation?
- Insanity (lack of criminal responsibility, Penal Law § 40.15) is a complete defense that requires proof the defendant lacked substantial capacity to know or appreciate the nature and consequences of the conduct or that it was wrong. EED requires much less, and it only reduces the charge.
- New Jersey has no EED defense. Its closest analogue is passion/provocation manslaughter, which requires adequate provocation and no cooling-off period (State v. Mauricio, 117 N.J. 402 (1990)). See New Jersey manslaughter. New York's EED is broader: it does not require a specific provoking act, and the disturbance can build over time.
Case result: Rockland County jury accepts EED
Mario M. Blanch, Esq. defended a client charged with murder in the second degree in Rockland County, New York. At trial he proved extreme emotional disturbance to the jury, which returned a manslaughter verdict. The client avoided a murder conviction and a possible sentence of life in prison. Read the case summary.
Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
The law: key statutes, court rules and cases
| Authority | What it means |
|---|---|
| Penal Law § 125.25 | Subdivision 1(a): the EED affirmative defense to intentional murder. |
| Penal Law § 125.20 | Subdivision 2: manslaughter in the first degree for an intentional killing under EED. |
| Penal Law § 125.27 | Subdivision 2(a): EED applies to first-degree murder. |
| Penal Law § 25.00 | The defendant proves an affirmative defense by a preponderance of the evidence. |
| CPL 250.10 | Notice required before offering psychiatric evidence in support of EED. |
| Penal Law § 40.15 | Insanity (lack of criminal responsibility) — a complete defense, distinct from EED. |
| People v. Casassa, 49 N.Y.2d 668 (1980) | Two-part EED test: actual disturbance (subjective) and a reasonable explanation or excuse (objective). |
| People v. Roche, 98 N.Y.2d 70 (2002) | EED requires proof of a mental infirmity short of insanity causing a loss of self-control; calculated conduct after the killing defeated the defense. |
| Patterson v. New York, 432 U.S. 197 (1977) | New York may require the defendant to prove EED by a preponderance. |
| People v. Patterson, 39 N.Y.2d 288 (1976) | Upheld New York's EED statute and burden allocation. |
Every authority links to its source: statutes to Justia, New Jersey opinions to CourtListener, U.S. Supreme Court opinions to Justia, court rules to the New Jersey Courts. Summaries are general information, not legal advice.
Official court resources and forms
The courts publish their own explanations and forms. They are useful background, and a lawyer can tell you which ones apply to your case.
Frequently asked questions
What is extreme emotional disturbance in New York?
Extreme emotional disturbance (EED) is an affirmative defense to intentional murder under Penal Law § 125.25(1)(a). If the defendant proves he acted under an extreme emotional disturbance with a reasonable explanation or excuse, the jury convicts of manslaughter in the first degree instead of murder.
Who must prove extreme emotional disturbance?
The defendant, by a preponderance of the evidence (Penal Law § 25.00(2)). The U.S. Supreme Court upheld this burden in Patterson v. New York, 432 U.S. 197 (1977).
What sentence follows a successful EED defense?
Manslaughter in the first degree under Penal Law § 125.20(2), a class B violent felony carrying a determinate sentence of 5 to 25 years plus post-release supervision, instead of murder's maximum of life.
Is extreme emotional disturbance the same as insanity?
No. Insanity under Penal Law § 40.15 is a complete defense. EED is a partial, mitigating defense that reduces murder to manslaughter and requires a lesser showing.
Does New Jersey have an extreme emotional disturbance defense?
No. New Jersey uses passion/provocation manslaughter, which requires adequate provocation and no time to cool off. New York's EED defense is broader.
General information only, not legal advice. Laws change; figures reflect statutes as of November 2026.