By Mario M. Blanch, Esq. · Published
Introduction
The administration of Standardized Field Sobriety Tests (SFSTs) by police officers is a critical component in the enforcement of DUI laws. Endorsed by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), these tests require strict adherence to standardized procedures. Notably, officers must score a 100% accuracy on the administration portion of their NHTSA SFST examination. This article argues that judges should suppress findings from officers who fail to conduct SFSTs in a standardized manner, highlighting the necessity for precision and fairness in legal processes. If an officer must score 100% proficiency in a classroom setting, our judicial system should not accept anything less.
The importance of standardization in SFSTs
- Scientific basis: SFSTs are developed based on scientific principles. Deviations from standardized procedures can lead to incorrect interpretations, undermining the scientific validity of the results.
- Legal fairness: The principle of fairness in the legal system mandates that evidence used in court must be reliable and gathered through proper methods. Non-standardized SFSTs compromise this fairness.
- Training and competence: Officers are rigorously trained to perform SFSTs. Not adhering to these standards raises questions about the officer's competence and the credibility of their findings.
Consequences of non-standardized SFSTs
- False positives: Deviating from standard procedures can lead to false positives, where sober individuals are incorrectly identified as impaired.
- Questionable evidence: Evidence obtained through non-standard means can be seen as unreliable, leading to challenges in court and potential miscarriages of justice.
- Undermining public trust: Consistency in law enforcement practices is crucial for maintaining public trust. Non-standardized tests can erode this trust.
Judicial responsibility
- Upholding the law: Judges have a duty to ensure that only reliable, scientifically valid evidence is presented in court.
- Setting precedents: By suppressing findings from non-standardized SFSTs, judges set a precedent that reinforces the importance of following proper procedures.
- Protecting rights: Ensuring that only evidence collected in a standardized manner is admitted in court is fundamental to protecting the rights of the accused.
Conclusion
The adherence to standard procedures in administering SFSTs is not just a guideline but a cornerstone of legal integrity. Judges play a pivotal role in upholding this integrity by suppressing findings from non-standardized tests. This practice not only ensures the fairness and reliability of the judicial process but also reinforces the standards of law enforcement, ultimately serving the cause of justice.
Talk to a lawyer about your case
If you are facing a charge or a family court matter in New Jersey or New York, request a free consultation or call 1-833-NY-NJ-LAW. See also: New Jersey DWI defense, New York DWI defense, Motions to suppress.
This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The law may have changed since it was written. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.