By Mario M. Blanch, Esq. · Published
Update: After this article was written, the New Jersey Supreme Court decided State v. Olenowski, 255 N.J. 529 (2023), holding that Drug Recognition Evaluation evidence is admissible in New Jersey subject to conditions and limits. The article below reflects the author's view at the time.
The recent New Jersey Supreme Court decision on Drug Recognition Experts fails to address the real issue lurking behind DREs and the dangers they pose. Rather than decide the issue, the Supreme Court handed the issue to a Special Master.
Drug recognition exams (DREs) are tests that are designed to determine whether a person is under the influence of drugs. These tests are typically administered by law enforcement officers who have undergone specialized training in DRE techniques. While DREs are often touted as a way to help identify impaired drivers and reduce the number of drug-related accidents on the road, there are many reasons why these exams should not be admissible in court.
First and foremost, DREs are not scientifically validated. Unlike breathalyzer tests, which are widely accepted as a reliable method of measuring a person's blood alcohol content, DREs have not been subjected to the same level of scientific scrutiny. In fact, the reliability and accuracy of DREs have been called into question by many experts in the field of toxicology.
One of the main issues with DREs is that they are highly subjective. Unlike objective tests like blood tests or breathalyzers, which measure a specific substance in the body, DREs rely on the subjective observations of the officer administering the test. This means that two different officers could administer the same test to the same person and come to completely different conclusions about whether that person is under the influence of drugs.
Another problem with DREs is that they are often influenced by the officer's personal biases and beliefs about drug use. For example, an officer who has been trained to believe that people who use marijuana are dangerous and unpredictable may be more likely to conclude that a person who appears to be under the influence of marijuana is a threat to public safety, even if there is no evidence to support that conclusion.
In addition, DREs are often administered in high-pressure situations, such as during a traffic stop or a roadside checkpoint. This can lead to errors in judgment and inaccurate conclusions about a person's level of impairment. In some cases, innocent people may be wrongly accused of drug use simply because an officer misinterpreted their behavior or appearance.
Perhaps most importantly, the use of DREs in court can lead to serious violations of a person's constitutional rights. Because DREs are so subjective and unreliable, there is a high risk that innocent people could be wrongly convicted of drug-related offenses. This is especially concerning given the significant penalties that are often associated with drug offenses, including fines, jail time, and loss of driving privileges.
In conclusion, while drug recognition exams may seem like a useful tool for law enforcement, there are many reasons why they should not be admissible in court. From their lack of scientific validation to their potential for subjectivity and bias, DREs are simply not a reliable way to determine whether a person is under the influence of drugs. As such, courts should exercise caution when considering the use of DREs in criminal cases and instead rely on more objective measures of impairment.
If you have been arrested or have questions about a DRE, contact our office. Blanch Legal, Mario M. Blanch, Esq., 1-833-NY-NJ-LAW.
Talk to a lawyer about your case
If you are facing a charge or a family court matter in New Jersey or New York, request a free consultation or call 1-833-NY-NJ-LAW. See also: New Jersey DWI defense, New York DWI defense, Motions to suppress.
This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The law may have changed since it was written. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.